| Played in Columbus (OH), OH, weather: 60 degrees, fair, 12 mph wind. |
| New York won the toss and elected to receive. |
| Start of first quarter. |
| (1Q: 15:00) Tommie Clark kicked off 61 yards from the COL30. Mo Fernandes returned the ball 25 yards to the NYK34. Tackled by Russell Gaylor. |
| 1-10-NYK34 (1Q: 14:23) Nate Rolf ran around right end for 9 yards. Tackled by CB Reggie Attico. Key block delivered by Brady Newhart. |
| 2-1-NYK43 (1Q: 13:37) Sean Poteat ran around the left tackle for 1 yard and was forced out of bounds. Tackled by DE Randy Turner, assisted by DT Carl Daniels. Key block delivered by Juan Munn. |
| 1-10-NYK44 (1Q: 12:54) Leslie Stokes pass fell incomplete, intended for C Brady Newhart. OLB Dominic Lafantaisie knocked the ball out of his grasp. |
| 2-10-NYK44 (1Q: 12:47) Leslie Stokes pass fell incomplete, intended for RB Nate Rolf. DE Thurman Gray hurried the quarterback into a bad throw. |
| 3-10-NYK44 (1Q: 12:43) Leslie Stokes pass was thrown incomplete, intended for WR Donny Porter. PENALTY: New York was called for Offensive Pass Interference. The penalty was declined. |
| 4-10-NYK44 (1Q: 12:33) Jared Reichardt punted 43 yards. Teddy Ingram returned the kick 6 yards to the COL19. Tackled by Claude Oshiro. |
| 1-10-COL19 (1Q: 12:26) Hardy Dennis ran inside the left guard for 5 yards. Tackled by OLB Nolan Snyder. Key block delivered by Frank Hopkins. Hopkins flattened Scottie Stuart to ensure the play's success. |
| 2-5-COL24 (1Q: 11:52) Hardy Dennis ran inside the right guard for 0 yards. Tackled by DE Vernon Kelly, assisted by OLB Scottie Stuart. |
| 3-5-COL24 (1Q: 11:09) Andy Benson pass fell incomplete, intended for WR Glenn Dejesus. CB Tony Iacuessa defended the pass. The quarterback threw away from the double coverage. |
| 4-5-COL24 (1Q: 11:00) Seth Karau punted 46 yards. The ball was downed at the NYK30. |
| 1-10-NYK30 (1Q: 10:49) Nate Rolf ran around left end for 2 yards. Tackled by DE Randy Turner. |
| 2-8-NYK32 (1Q: 10:04) Leslie Stokes pass completed to C Brady Newhart for 9 yards. The receiver went out of bounds. Tackled by CB Reggie Attico. Newhart gained 1 yard after the catch. |
| 1-10-NYK41 (1Q: 09:31) Nate Rolf ran around left end for 26 yards. Tackled by CB Teddy Bauer. Key block delivered by Renaldo Winslett. PENALTY: New York was called for Offensive Holding. |
| 1-20-NYK31 (1Q: 09:18) Leslie Stokes pass fell incomplete, intended for RB Nate Rolf. CB Kendrick Myers defended the pass. |
| 2-20-NYK31 (1Q: 09:10) Leslie Stokes pass fell incomplete, intended for WR Edward Wayne. DE Shane Martell hurried the quarterback into a bad throw. |
| 3-20-NYK31 (1Q: 09:05) Leslie Stokes pass was dropped by WR Dana Eickholt. |
| 4-20-NYK31 (1Q: 08:57) Jared Reichardt punted 29 yards. Teddy Ingram returned the kick 0 yards to the COL40. Tackled by Lonnie Goldwater. |
| 1-10-COL40 (1Q: 08:49) PENALTY: Columbus (OH) was called for a False Start. |
| 1-15-COL35 (1Q: 08:43) Andy Benson pass completed to RB Russell Gaylor for 5 yards. Tackled by OLB Arnold Meadows, assisted by OLB Nolan Snyder. Gaylor gained 1 yard after the catch. |
| 2-10-COL40 (1Q: 07:56) Andy Benson pass fell incomplete, intended for WR Glenn Dejesus. CB Seth Wehmeyer knocked the ball out of his grasp. The quarterback threw into double coverage. |
| 3-10-COL40 (1Q: 07:48) Andy Benson pass completed to TE One Way Street for 20 yards. Tackled by CB Seth Wehmeyer. The receiver ran his route right over the middle of the field. Street gained 2 yards after the catch. |
| 1-10-NYK40 (1Q: 07:17) Andy Benson pass was dropped by WR Nicky Malone. The quarterback threw into double coverage. PENALTY: New York was called for Unnecessary Roughness. |
| 1-10-NYK25 (1Q: 07:11) Andy Benson pass completed to WR Nicky Malone for 16 yards. Tackled by OLB Nolan Snyder. The receiver ran his route right over the middle of the field. Malone gained 2 yards after the catch. |
| 1-9-NYK09 (1Q: 06:33) Hardy Dennis ran around the left tackle for -1 yards. Tackled by DT Joseph Breland. PENALTY: Columbus (OH) was called for Offensive Holding. |
| 1-19-NYK19 (1Q: 06:23) Hardy Dennis ran around right end for 5 yards. Tackled by S Wade Barker, assisted by S Scott Devine. Key block delivered by Shaun Blalock. |
| 2-14-NYK14 (1Q: 05:50) Hardy Dennis ran around left end for 7 yards. Tackled by S Butch Farr. |
| 3-7-NYK07 (1Q: 05:22) Andy Benson scrambled for 3 yards. Tackled by OLB Scottie Stuart. |
| 4-4-NYK04 (1Q: 04:41) Edward Washington attempted a 21 yard field goal and succeeded. Columbus (OH) 3, New York 0 |
| (1Q: 04:36) Tommie Clark kicked off 66 yards from the COL30. Mo Fernandes returned the ball 23 yards to the NYK27. Tackled by Brent Giles. PENALTY: New York was called for Clipping on the Kick Return. |
| 1-10-NYK07 (1Q: 04:04) Sean Poteat ran around right end for 5 yards. Tackled by S Marvin Goodwin. Key block delivered by Joseph Sanders. |
| 2-5-NYK12 (1Q: 03:34) Sean Poteat ran around left end for 8 yards. Tackled by OLB Lawrence Yovanovits, assisted by S Irving Farr. Key block delivered by Everett Woodard. |
| 1-10-NYK20 (1Q: 02:54) Leslie Stokes scrambled for 4 yards. Tackled by CB Kendrick Myers. |
| 2-6-NYK24 (1Q: 02:23) Sean Poteat ran around the left tackle for -2 yards. Tackled by DT Rico Douglas. |
| 3-8-NYK22 (1Q: 01:47) Leslie Stokes pass completed to WR Edward Wayne for 6 yards. Tackled by CB Reggie Attico. |
| 4-2-NYK28 (1Q: 01:02) Jared Reichardt punted 46 yards. Teddy Ingram returned the kick 10 yards to the COL36. Tackled by Lonnie Goldwater. |
| 1-10-COL36 (1Q: 00:52) Andy Benson pass was intended for WR Nicky Malone and was intercepted by ILB Tony Schelling at the NYK46. The interception was returned 1 yard. Tackled by Nicky Malone. The quarterback threw away from the double coverage. |
| 1-10-NYK47 (1Q: 00:42) Leslie Stokes pass completed to WR Edward Wayne for 4 yards. Tackled by CB Teddy Bauer. The receiver ran his route right over the middle of the field. |
| 2-6-COL49 (1Q: 00:10) Leslie Stokes kept the ball, running around the left tackle for 49 yards and a TOUCHDOWN! Key block delivered by Renaldo Winslett. New York 6, Columbus (OH) 3 |
| (1Q: 00:10) Extra point by Brady Abdul-Malik was good. New York 7, Columbus (OH) 3 |
| Start of second quarter. |
| (2Q: 15:00) Brady Abdul-Malik kicked off 63 yards from the NYK30. Terrell Crawford returned the ball 25 yards to the COL32. Tackled by Butch Farr. |
| 1-10-COL32 (2Q: 14:23) Hardy Dennis ran inside the right guard for 12 yards. Tackled by S Scott Devine, assisted by CB Tony Iacuessa. Key block delivered by Frank Hopkins. Hopkins flattened Tony Schelling to ensure the play's success. |
| 1-10-COL44 (2Q: 13:38) Russell Gaylor ran inside the right guard for 6 yards. Tackled by ILB Tony Schelling. Key block delivered by Herb Whitfield. |
| 2-4-COL50 (2Q: 13:04) Andy Benson pass fell incomplete, intended for WR Terrell Crawford. DT Brandon Weaver hurried the quarterback into a bad throw. The quarterback threw away from the double coverage. |
| 3-4-COL50 (2Q: 12:59) Andy Benson pass completed to WR Marcus Ford for 10 yards. Tackled by CB Tony Iacuessa, assisted by ILB Tony Schelling. |
| 1-10-NYK40 (2Q: 12:14) Andy Benson pass was thrown incomplete, intended for WR Terrell Crawford. The quarterback threw away from the double coverage. |
| 2-10-NYK40 (2Q: 12:05) Russell Gaylor ran inside the right guard for -2 yards. Tackled by DT Dana Wanat, assisted by DT Zach Torgerson. PENALTY: New York was called for Unnecessary Roughness. |
| 1-10-NYK27 (2Q: 11:55) Hardy Dennis ran inside the right guard for 0 yards. Tackled by S Butch Farr, assisted by OLB Arnold Meadows. DT Joseph Breland knocked down Doug Pittman to break up the play. |
| 2-10-NYK27 (2Q: 11:24) Hardy Dennis ran a draw inside the left guard for -4 yards. Tackled by ILB Tony Schelling. PENALTY: New York was called for an Intentional Face Mask. |
| 1-10-NYK16 (2Q: 11:16) Andy Benson pass completed to WR Marcus Ford for 16 yards and a TOUCHDOWN! The quarterback threw into double coverage. Columbus (OH) 9, New York 7 |
| (2Q: 11:16) Extra point by Edward Washington was good. Columbus (OH) 10, New York 7 |
| (2Q: 11:09) Tommie Clark kicked off 61 yards from the COL30. Mo Fernandes returned the ball 29 yards to the NYK38. Tackled by Kendrick Myers. |
| 1-10-NYK38 (2Q: 10:41) Sean Poteat ran inside the left guard for 2 yards. Tackled by OLB Lawrence Yovanovits. |
| 2-8-NYK40 (2Q: 10:10) Leslie Stokes pass completed to WR Donny Porter for 12 yards. Tackled by ILB Edgar Dillard. Porter gained 5 yards after the catch. |
| 1-10-COL48 (2Q: 09:36) Sean Poteat ran around right end for 2 yards. Tackled by DT Fernando Westbrook. |
| 2-8-COL46 (2Q: 09:02) Leslie Stokes pass fell incomplete, intended for WR Dana Eickholt. DE Thurman Gray simply tossed Earl Webb aside to reach the quarterback and hurry the throw. |
| 3-8-COL46 (2Q: 08:58) Leslie Stokes pass completed to WR Edward Wayne for 11 yards. Tackled by ILB Edgar Dillard. |
| 1-10-COL35 (2Q: 08:29) Leslie Stokes pass completed to WR Edward Wayne for 27 yards. Tackled by S Irving Farr. The receiver ran his route right over the middle of the field. Wayne gained 5 yards after the catch. |
| 1-8-COL08 (2Q: 07:52) Leslie Stokes pass was blocked at the line, intended for WR Donny Porter. DT Carl Daniels blocked the pass. |
| 2-8-COL08 (2Q: 07:44) Nate Rolf ran around left end for 8 yards and a TOUCHDOWN! Key block delivered by Geoff Matthews. New York 13, Columbus (OH) 10 |
| (2Q: 07:44) Extra point by Brady Abdul-Malik was good. New York 14, Columbus (OH) 10 |
| (2Q: 07:37) Brady Abdul-Malik kicked off 72 yards from the NYK30. Touchback. |
| 1-10-COL20 (2Q: 07:37) Andy Benson sacked by DE Vince Williams for a loss of 4 yards. Sack allowed by Shane Maxwell. |
| 2-14-COL16 (2Q: 06:53) Andy Benson sacked by DE Gerald Knight for a loss of 6 yards. Sack allowed by Matthew Oskolkoff. The ball was fumbled and recovered by COL Percy Mueller on the COL10. |
| 3-20-COL10 (2Q: 06:15) Andy Benson pass completed to WR Marcus Ford for 40 yards. Tackled by OLB Scottie Stuart. Ford gained 33 yards after the catch. The quarterback threw away from the double coverage. |
| 1-10-COL50 (2Q: 05:29) Teddy Ingram ran inside the left guard for 1 yard. Tackled by OLB Scottie Stuart. |
| 2-9-NYK49 (2Q: 05:04) Andy Benson pass completed to WR Marcus Ford for 28 yards. Tackled by CB Mo Fernandes. The receiver ran his route right over the middle of the field. Ford gained 14 yards after the catch. The quarterback threw away from the double coverage. |
| 1-10-NYK21 (2Q: 04:21) Andy Benson pass completed to WR Glenn Dejesus for 13 yards. The receiver went out of bounds. Tackled by CB Seth Wehmeyer. |
| 1-8-NYK08 (2Q: 03:51) Andy Benson pass fell incomplete, intended for TE Percy Mueller. DE Vernon Kelly hurried the quarterback into a bad throw. The quarterback threw away from the double coverage. |
| 2-8-NYK08 (2Q: 03:42) Andy Benson pass completed to RB Russell Gaylor for 1 yard. Tackled by OLB Arnold Meadows. |
| 3-7-NYK07 (2Q: 03:20) Andy Benson pass completed to WR Marcus Ford for 3 yards. Tackled by ILB Tony Schelling. The quarterback threw away from the double coverage. PENALTY: Columbus (OH) was called for Offensive Holding. The penalty was declined. |
| 4-4-NYK04 (2Q: 03:12) Edward Washington attempted a 21 yard field goal and succeeded. New York 14, Columbus (OH) 13 |
| (2Q: 03:06) Tommie Clark kicked off 63 yards from the COL30. Mo Fernandes returned the ball 17 yards to the NYK24. Tackled by Reggie Attico. |
| 1-10-NYK24 (2Q: 02:45) Leslie Stokes pass completed to WR Donny Porter for 6 yards. Tackled by ILB Edgar Dillard. PENALTY: Columbus (OH) was called for Offsides. |
| 1-5-NYK29 (2Q: 02:45) Leslie Stokes scrambled for 2 yards. Tackled by CB Reggie Attico. |
| 2-3-NYK31 (2Q: 02:07) Sean Poteat ran outside the right tackle for 4 yards. Tackled by OLB Dominic Lafantaisie, assisted by DT Carl Daniels. Key block delivered by Earl Webb. PENALTY: New York was called for Illegal Motion. |
| 2-8-NYK26 (2Q: 02:07) Leslie Stokes pass fell incomplete, intended for TE Wally Cerf. DE Randy Turner hurried the quarterback into a bad throw. |
| Official time out for the two-minute warning. |
| 3-8-NYK26 (2Q: 01:58) Leslie Stokes pass completed to WR Dana Eickholt for 11 yards. Tackled by DT Fernando Westbrook. Eickholt gained 3 yards after the catch. |
| 1-10-NYK37 (2Q: 01:12) Nate Rolf ran outside the right tackle for 4 yards. Tackled by DE Thurman Gray. |
| 2-6-NYK41 (2Q: 00:37) Leslie Stokes pass completed to C Brady Newhart for 36 yards. Tackled by CB Reggie Attico. Newhart gained 24 yards after the catch. |
| 1-10-COL23 (2Q: 00:21) Leslie Stokes pass was intended for WR Dana Eickholt and was intercepted by CB Teddy Bauer in the end zone. Touchback. |
| 1-10-COL20 (2Q: 00:10) Andy Benson pass was blocked at the line, intended for WR Nicky Malone. DE Gerald Knight blocked the pass. |
| 2-10-COL20 (2Q: 00:03) Andy Benson pass completed to WR Nicky Malone for 14 yards. Tackled by CB Mo Fernandes, assisted by S Wade Barker. The quarterback threw away from the double coverage. |
| Start of third quarter. |
| (3Q: 15:00) Brady Abdul-Malik kicked off 79 yards from the NYK30. Touchback. |
| 1-10-COL20 (3Q: 15:00) Russell Gaylor ran inside the right tackle for 5 yards. Tackled by DE Vince Williams. Key block delivered by Cornell Schenk. |
| 2-5-COL25 (3Q: 14:20) Andy Benson pass was blocked at the line, intended for WR Nicky Malone. DE Vince Williams blocked the pass. |
| 3-5-COL25 (3Q: 14:15) Andy Benson pass fell incomplete, intended for WR Terrell Crawford. OLB Scottie Stuart defended the pass. The quarterback threw into double coverage. |
| 4-5-COL25 (3Q: 14:11) Seth Karau punted 54 yards. Edward Wayne returned the kick 4 yards to the NYK25. Tackled by Reggie Attico. |
| 1-10-NYK25 (3Q: 14:03) Nate Rolf ran around right end for 10 yards. Tackled by ILB Edgar Dillard, assisted by DE Shane Martell. Key block delivered by Earl Webb. Webb ran over Teddy Bauer to set up the play. |
| 1-10-NYK35 (3Q: 13:29) Nate Rolf ran around left end for 2 yards. Tackled by DE Shane Martell, assisted by OLB Dominic Lafantaisie. |
| 2-8-NYK37 (3Q: 13:00) Leslie Stokes scrambled for 4 yards. Tackled by CB Reggie Attico. PENALTY: New York was called for an Illegal Formation. |
| 2-13-NYK32 (3Q: 12:50) Leslie Stokes pass was dropped by WR Dana Eickholt. |
| 3-13-NYK32 (3Q: 12:40) PENALTY: New York was called for a False Start. |
| 3-18-NYK27 (3Q: 12:31) Leslie Stokes pass completed to WR Edward Wayne for 13 yards. Tackled by S Marvin Goodwin, assisted by OLB Lawrence Yovanovits. |
| 4-5-NYK40 (3Q: 11:46) Jared Reichardt punted 43 yards. Teddy Ingram returned the kick 11 yards to the COL28. Tackled by Clifton Keith. Ball was fumbled and recovered by COL Brent Kooistra at the COL28. |
| 1-10-COL28 (3Q: 11:39) Andy Benson pass was intended for WR Rusty Stargell and was intercepted by ILB Terrell Klote at the COL43. The interception was returned 26 yards. Tackled by Antoine Kirk. |
| 1-10-COL17 (3Q: 11:29) Leslie Stokes pass completed to WR Edward Wayne for 3 yards. Tackled by CB Kendrick Myers. |
| 2-7-COL14 (3Q: 11:01) Leslie Stokes pass completed to WR Dana Eickholt for 9 yards. Tackled by CB Kendrick Myers, assisted by CB Reggie Attico. The receiver ran his route right over the middle of the field. |
| 1-5-COL05 (3Q: 10:31) Leslie Stokes sacked by DE Randy Turner for a loss of 6 yards. Sack allowed by Everett Woodard. |
| 2-11-COL11 (3Q: 09:57) Leslie Stokes pass fell incomplete, intended for WR Donny Porter. DE Thurman Gray drove right through Geoff Matthews to hurry the quarterback. |
| 3-11-COL11 (3Q: 09:53) Leslie Stokes pass was blocked at the line, intended for WR Edward Wayne. OLB Lawrence Yovanovits blocked the pass. |
| 4-11-COL11 (3Q: 09:45) Brady Abdul-Malik attempted a 28 yard field goal and succeeded. New York 17, Columbus (OH) 13 |
| (3Q: 09:37) Brady Abdul-Malik kicked off 49 yards from the NYK30. Teddy Ingram returned the ball 20 yards to the COL41. Tackled by Louis Guillen. |
| 1-10-COL41 (3Q: 09:08) Andy Benson pass fell incomplete, intended for RB Hardy Dennis. CB Tony Iacuessa defended the pass. The quarterback threw away from the double coverage. |
| 2-10-COL41 (3Q: 09:02) Andy Benson pass fell incomplete, intended for WR Marcus Ford. DT Dana Wanat hurried the quarterback into a bad throw. The quarterback threw away from the double coverage. |
| 3-10-COL41 (3Q: 08:52) Andy Benson pass completed to RB Russell Gaylor for 0 yards. Tackled by DT Dana Wanat, assisted by ILB Tony Schelling. |
| 4-10-COL41 (3Q: 08:13) Seth Karau punted 41 yards. Edward Wayne returned the kick 5 yards to the NYK23. Tackled by Reggie Attico. Columbus (OH)'s Teddy Ingram was hurt on the play. |
| 1-10-NYK23 (3Q: 08:03) Nate Rolf ran inside the right guard for 4 yards. Tackled by S Irving Farr. |
| 2-6-NYK27 (3Q: 07:29) Sean Poteat ran around right end for 1 yard. Tackled by OLB Lawrence Yovanovits, assisted by S Marvin Goodwin. |
| 3-5-NYK28 (3Q: 06:48) Leslie Stokes sacked by DT Tyrell Hitchcock for a loss of 6 yards. Sack allowed by Juan Munn. The defense looked very familiar with that play. The ball was fumbled and recovered by NYK Claude Oshiro on the NYK22. |
| 4-11-NYK22 (3Q: 06:04) Jared Reichardt punted and it was blocked by Nicky Malone. COL Brent Kooistra recovered the ball at the NYK11. |
| 1-10-NYK11 (3Q: 05:56) Andy Benson pass was thrown incomplete, intended for TE Bo Street. |
| 2-10-NYK11 (3Q: 05:52) Russell Gaylor ran inside the left tackle for -1 yards. Tackled by S Butch Farr. |
| 3-11-NYK12 (3Q: 05:26) Andy Benson pass completed to WR Marcus Ford for 3 yards. Tackled by CB Tony Iacuessa. The quarterback threw away from the double coverage. |
| 4-8-NYK09 (3Q: 04:57) Edward Washington attempted a 26 yard field goal and succeeded. New York 17, Columbus (OH) 16 |
| (3Q: 04:50) Tommie Clark kicked off 58 yards from the COL30. Mo Fernandes returned the ball 32 yards to the NYK44. Tackled by Russell Gaylor. |
| 1-10-NYK44 (3Q: 04:17) Sean Poteat ran around right end for 3 yards. Tackled by CB Kendrick Myers. |
| 2-7-NYK47 (3Q: 03:35) Leslie Stokes pass fell incomplete, intended for WR Edward Wayne. OLB Lawrence Yovanovits defended the pass. The defense looked very familiar with that play. |
| 3-7-NYK47 (3Q: 03:28) Leslie Stokes pass completed to C Brady Newhart for 10 yards. Tackled by CB Teddy Bauer. Newhart gained 5 yards after the catch. |
| 1-10-COL43 (3Q: 02:43) Sean Poteat ran inside the left guard for 5 yards. Tackled by S Brent Giles. Key block delivered by Harvey Brady. |
| 2-5-COL38 (3Q: 01:58) Sean Poteat ran inside the right guard for 2 yards. Tackled by OLB Lawrence Yovanovits. |
| 3-3-COL36 (3Q: 01:26) Leslie Stokes pass was blocked at the line, intended for RB Nate Rolf. OLB Brent Kooistra blocked the pass. The defense looked extremely familiar with that play. |
| 4-3-COL36 (3Q: 01:22) Leslie Stokes pass fell incomplete, intended for WR Edward Wayne. DE Thurman Gray hurried the quarterback into a bad throw. The defense looked very familiar with that play. The ball goes over on downs. |
| 1-10-COL36 (3Q: 01:18) Hardy Dennis ran around right end for 44 yards. Tackled by ILB Tony Schelling. Key block delivered by Kyle Lowe. |
| 1-10-NYK20 (3Q: 00:48) Andy Benson pass completed to FB Gabe Howe for 3 yards. Tackled by OLB Arnold Meadows, assisted by S Butch Farr. The quarterback threw away from the double coverage. |
| 2-7-NYK17 (3Q: 00:06) Russell Gaylor ran inside the right guard for 5 yards. Tackled by DT Dana Wanat, assisted by CB Tony Iacuessa. |
| Start of fourth quarter. |
| 3-2-NYK12 (4Q: 15:00) Russell Gaylor ran inside the left guard for 2 yards. Tackled by DT Dana Wanat. Key block delivered by Frank Hopkins. |
| 1-10-NYK10 (4Q: 14:30) Emmitt Drake ran around left end for 9 yards. Tackled by ILB Tony Schelling. Key block delivered by Matthew Oskolkoff. |
| 2-1-NYK01 (4Q: 14:04) Hardy Dennis ran inside the left tackle for 1 yard and a TOUCHDOWN! Key block delivered by Doug Pittman. Columbus (OH) 22, New York 17 |
| (4Q: 14:04) Extra point by Edward Washington was good. Columbus (OH) 23, New York 17 |
| (4Q: 13:55) Tommie Clark kicked off 61 yards from the COL30. Mo Fernandes returned the ball 28 yards to the NYK37. Tackled by Brent Giles. |
| 1-10-NYK37 (4Q: 13:35) Nate Rolf ran outside the right tackle for 2 yards. Tackled by S Brent Giles. OLB Lawrence Yovanovits knocked down Everett Woodard to break up the play. |
| 2-8-NYK39 (4Q: 13:04) Nate Rolf ran inside the left tackle for -1 yards. Tackled by S Irving Farr. |
| 3-9-NYK38 (4Q: 12:19) Sean Poteat ran around right end for 5 yards. Tackled by DE Randy Turner, assisted by S Irving Farr. |
| 4-4-NYK43 (4Q: 11:33) Jared Reichardt punted 38 yards. Terrell Crawford returned the kick 7 yards to the COL26. Tackled by Louis Guillen. |
| 1-10-COL26 (4Q: 11:25) Gabe Howe ran around left end for 3 yards. Tackled by CB Tony Iacuessa, assisted by S Scott Devine. |
| 2-7-COL29 (4Q: 10:43) Andy Benson pass completed to WR Nicky Malone for 4 yards. Tackled by OLB Arnold Meadows. Malone gained 4 yards after the catch. |
| 3-3-COL33 (4Q: 10:08) Andy Benson pass completed to WR Marcus Ford for 13 yards. Tackled by DT Joseph Breland. Ford gained 4 yards after the catch. The quarterback threw away from the double coverage. |
| 1-10-COL46 (4Q: 09:40) Andy Benson pass completed to WR Glenn Dejesus for 24 yards. The receiver went out of bounds. Tackled by ILB Tony Schelling, assisted by S Butch Farr. Dejesus gained 7 yards after the catch. The quarterback threw into double coverage. |
| 1-10-NYK30 (4Q: 09:00) Andy Benson pass fell incomplete, intended for WR Glenn Dejesus. S Scott Devine defended the pass. The quarterback threw away from the double coverage. |
| 2-10-NYK30 (4Q: 08:54) Andy Benson pass fell incomplete, intended for WR Marcus Ford. ILB Tony Schelling knocked the ball out of his grasp. The quarterback threw into double coverage. |
| 3-10-NYK30 (4Q: 08:45) Andy Benson scrambled for 4 yards. Tackled by CB Mo Fernandes. |
| 4-6-NYK26 (4Q: 08:11) Edward Washington attempted a 43 yard field goal and succeeded. Columbus (OH) 26, New York 17 |
| (4Q: 08:05) Tommie Clark kicked off 79 yards from the COL30. Touchback. |
| 1-10-NYK20 (4Q: 08:05) Nate Rolf ran around left end for -4 yards. Tackled by DT Rico Douglas. |
| 2-14-NYK16 (4Q: 07:37) Leslie Stokes pass fell incomplete, intended for WR Ellis Taggart. CB Teddy Bauer defended the pass. The defense looked very familiar with that play. |
| 3-14-NYK16 (4Q: 07:27) Leslie Stokes scrambled for 6 yards. Tackled by S Marvin Goodwin. |
| 4-8-NYK22 (4Q: 06:46) Jared Reichardt punted 56 yards. Terrell Crawford returned the kick 15 yards to the COL37. Tackled by Joseph Sanders. |
| 1-10-COL37 (4Q: 06:38) Russell Gaylor ran inside the right guard for 8 yards. Tackled by DT Brandon Weaver. Key block delivered by Herb Whitfield. |
| 2-2-COL45 (4Q: 05:50) Hardy Dennis ran a draw inside the left guard for 5 yards. Tackled by ILB Terrell Klote, assisted by S Wade Barker. Key block delivered by Doug Pittman. |
| 1-10-COL50 (4Q: 05:05) Russell Gaylor ran around the left tackle for 5 yards. Tackled by S Scott Devine, assisted by DE Gerald Knight. The ball was fumbled and recovered by COL Glenn Dejesus to the NYK45. |
| 2-5-NYK45 (4Q: 04:19) Emmitt Drake ran around left end for 2 yards. Tackled by OLB Nolan Snyder, assisted by S Wade Barker. |
| 3-3-NYK43 (4Q: 03:33) Emmitt Drake ran inside the left guard for 4 yards. Tackled by DT Brandon Weaver. Key block delivered by Doug Pittman. |
| 1-10-NYK39 (4Q: 02:48) Hardy Dennis ran a trap outside the left tackle for 5 yards and was forced out of bounds. Tackled by DE Gerald Knight, assisted by DT Brandon Weaver. Key block delivered by Doug Pittman. Pittman ran over Butch Farr to set up the play. |
| 2-5-NYK34 (4Q: 02:37) Percy Mueller ran inside the right tackle for 2 yards. Tackled by ILB Terrell Klote, assisted by S Wade Barker. |
| New York called a time out. |
| 3-3-NYK32 (4Q: 02:26) Hardy Dennis ran inside the left tackle for 1 yard. Tackled by DE Vernon Kelly, assisted by CB Mo Fernandes. |
| New York called a time out. |
| 4-2-NYK31 (4Q: 02:14) Edward Washington attempted a 48 yard field goal and succeeded. Columbus (OH) 29, New York 17 |
| (4Q: 02:07) Tommie Clark kicked off 67 yards from the COL30. Mo Fernandes returned the ball 22 yards to the NYK25. Tackled by Reggie Attico. |
| Official time out for the two-minute warning. |
| 1-10-NYK25 (4Q: 01:59) Leslie Stokes pass was thrown incomplete, intended for WR Edward Wayne. PENALTY: Columbus (OH) was called for Unnecessary Roughness. |
| 1-10-NYK40 (4Q: 01:50) Leslie Stokes pass fell incomplete, intended for WR Edward Wayne. DT Carl Daniels hurried the quarterback into a bad throw. |
| 2-10-NYK40 (4Q: 01:42) Leslie Stokes sacked by DE Thurman Gray for a loss of 16 yards. Sack allowed by Juan Munn. |
| 3-26-NYK24 (4Q: 01:20) Leslie Stokes pass was intended for WR Donny Porter and was intercepted by S Marvin Goodwin at the NYK37. Tackled by Donny Porter. |
| 1-10-NYK37 (4Q: 01:10) Russell Gaylor ran inside the left tackle for 4 yards. Tackled by ILB Terrell Klote, assisted by DE Gerald Knight. |
| New York called a time out. |
| 2-6-NYK33 (4Q: 01:00) Russell Gaylor ran inside the right guard for 3 yards. Tackled by DT Brandon Weaver. |
| 3-3-NYK30 (4Q: 00:14) Andy Benson dropped to one knee for -1 yards. |
| Final Score: Columbus (OH) Wardogs 29, New York Blizzard 17 |